Dr. Kenneth Lloyd has spent years looking into what works and what doesn't
in the workplace. He is now letting the rest of us in on his findings.
Lloyd has written several books, including Jerks at Work: How to Deal with
People Problems and Problem People.
In addition to his books, Lloyd's weekly syndicated column On the
Job appears in over two dozen newspapers throughout North America.
In a recent interview, Lloyd gave a little insight into how you can deal
with jerks at work and how you can avoid being one yourself.
Q: What prompted you to write Jerks at Work: How to Deal with People
Problems and Problem People? Was it the success of your column?
A: It's interesting. I got so many letters and certainly a ton of e-mail
saying, "Are [the columns] available in a book? We like them. We enjoy reading
them. Is there any way to get more of them?"
With a column, the words are written. They're out there, they're
read and then they're gone. If somebody doesn't read the paper that
day or whatever, they can miss something that, as a writer, you feel could
be kind of interesting and important.
So, when I started getting this feedback from the readers and really looked
at what was here, I realized that this could be something that people may
in fact enjoy having and may be useful to them in a number of different ways.
So that's when I really decided to pull out what I thought were the key
columns in a number of areas.
I wanted it to be a fun read as well, so I took out the columns that I
thought were particularly interesting and some that focused on some rather
bizarre behaviors at work and put it all into the mix.
Q: Obviously, your background in organizational behavior was a great
help to you when researching this book. Did you find that the "problem people"
or the "people problems" that you dealt with tended to fall into a few definite
categories?
A: Ultimately, they do fall into different classifications and categories.
But at the same time, the behaviors at the workplace are just as broad as
you find in society at large.
You'll see some falling into issues of communication or various kinds
of baggage that people were bringing into work. You'll see a whole range
of problems coming in from family businesses and that type of thing.
Q: Are the personal traits that so-called problem people bring to a
job likely to cause problems no matter what?
A: People do obviously bring their personalities in to work and they will
wear a lot of that on the job. But there is no question that what goes on
in that environment -- whether it's by a manager or by co-workers or
by various policies -- will have an impact.
So it's whatever the individual is bringing in, and then how that
interacts with the particular environment. So it depends on a lot of factors.
Q: Do you find different types of problems at different income levels?
A: Job levels can allow different kinds of behaviors. For example, we might
have someone who's late frequently for work. Now if that's a manager
or a boss, then you've got employees trying to cover and the employees
feel upset.
There are ways to deal with it and we try to give some recommendations.
But at the same time, you can see other employees at the lowest level of the
organizational structure who are late all the time. They get treated very
differently. Things get documented and either they get with the program or
they've got real problems.
But it could be a company issue, too. Maybe the company should be more
flexible and put in some flex time and so forth.
Q: I would assume that in addition to teaching people to recognize
potential problems with their co-workers, your book will also offer advice
to individuals about how they can avoid becoming "problem workers" themselves.
A: Sometimes I'll get a letter in, and the person will complain about
a co-worker or boss when in fact, it's that person who is being the problem.
And I have to say that.
Sometimes I will write back and say, "You've mentioned that this individual
keeps accusing you of doing these things, but at the same time in the letter
you mention that you took action X, Y and Z. Couldn't that actually have
caused the behavior in the first place?"
So I do, at the end of the book, have a number of suggestions to avoid
being a jerk, because frankly we all can and we probably all at one point
or another have acted like a jerk at work.
But I try to give a listing of the kinds of behaviors and things to think
about to avoid being a jerk. Be honest, communicate openly, keep your cool
and be a team a player, be fair and ethical.
Frankly, the bottom line on not being a jerk really goes back to the golden
rule. If you apply that at work, your probability of being a jerk is going
to drop way down.
Q: How can career counselors best prepare students for the difficulties
of the workplace?
A: There are studies out there -- long-term studies -- that show that a lot
of the behaviors that you see present among young people in high school (being
industrious, persistent, cheerful) tend to be long-term characteristics.
There are long-term studies that show that people who were cheerful as
teenagers are still cheerful in their 70s and beyond. From that standpoint,
high school is a great place to be really setting in the kinds of values and
behaviors that you would like to continue to develop as you go on in your
career.
And frankly, if you've been out of high school for quite a while and
you go back to a reunion, you see that a lot of people haven't changed
all that much. They really haven't.
Q: Is a lot of this advice something the reader can use on the job,
at home and at play?
A: No question about it. Because, again, if you take the best way to avoid
being a jerk is to live by the golden rule, certainly that applies to dealing
with one's family, friends and any others that you come into contact
with during the course of your life.
There certainly can be people who act like jerks as parents or as siblings
or as children. And there are things that can be done in those arenas as well
to prevent some of the problems and certainly to deal with them.
Q: While you were researching Jerks at Work, did you learn anything
new about yourself?
A: It made me really stop and think, "Have I ever really acted like a real
jerk at work?" And the answer is yes. Yes, I have.
And I think the key thing is that it's not enough to say, "Gosh, I
shouldn't have done that" or "That was really a mistake." The key is
to not repeat that behavior again.
So if you got upset over something or if you said something that you shouldn't
have said, and you say to yourself, "Gee, looking back at that, that was a
real mistake," it means nothing. Even if you go and apologize, it means nothing
unless you truly commit not to repeat that behavior again. Then you're
going to grow and you're really going to learn from it.
So if you find that you've acted as a jerk, it's not enough to
say, "Boy, I'm sorry, I really messed up." What you really need to do
is commit to yourself not to do it again.